marlinguy wrote on Aug 9
th, 2025 at 12:18am:
ssdave wrote on Aug 8
th, 2025 at 9:55pm:
The straight octagon (no taper) Green mountain barrels were intended for muzzle loaders and are indeed of leaded steel.
Dave are you saying any GM barrel that's straight octagon and not tapered is a muzzleloader barrel? That's not quite true if that's what you mean. GM lists straight octagon barrels on their site as "BPCR barrels" which I'd take to mean black powder CARTRIDGE rifle barrels. They sell them as straight octagon, and straight round both, plus tapered octagon too.
(You need to Login or Register to view media files and links) No, just those old, straight, slightly smaller barrels that were a bit under 1-1/8". The other distinguising feature I remember of them was the finish. They are polished well, and have a unique polished radius on the ends. The newer, heavy BPCR barrels are larger diameter and aren't finished that way.
I remember when GM first started moving from muzzleloader barrels into more mainstream barrels. I bought a lot of barrels from them that I contoured, and/or resold. I remember when these barrels were offered, and they clearly stated the material at that time, and if you called them, they told you to use their other barrels instead if you were building a cartridge gun. These were 1/2 the price or less of a cro-moly barrel at the beginning, and were 1/4 the price when they closed them out. The distinguising feature of them was that they were less than 1-1/8".
These barrels were bought by many thinking they were cartridge rifle steel. A lot of them were not used, because knowledgeable gunsmiths refused to chamber them in modern cartridges. So, they resurface over and over again, on ebay or gun boards at an attractive price. At least the seller in this case clearly disclosed that they were not cro-moly barrels. On ebay they are just usually sold as mystery barrels.
It's more or less a free country, and individuals are free to make their own choices on whether or not to use them for cartridge guns. As Wes Turner said, his haven't blown up yet. I'd just prefer to not take that chance, and much appreciate having a larger margin of safety against disaster if I make an error in loading. And, not have to worry about fatigue cycles in the steel.