Rockwell Testers use a Ball penetrator for Brinell Hardness. Also a Rotatable
weight system for the Brinell load. In the Rockwell Scale when you get material
below 28-30 Rockwell it becomes unreliable. In Brinell if you have it setup right the indicator face has a Brinell scale so you can read it directly. Now the SAECO hardness instructions indicate you can recreate Alloy by meeting certain hardness and thus create the same as pure lead Tin alloys. WRONG!
Alloy is alloy, Lead, Tin means LEAD/TIN only. The one constant that is lost is Chemistry. For many years I have been told by Men who would say "Antimony and Black Powder don't MIX" I was at that time using Linotype
as a Base for making my Alloy's up and checking hardness by squashing a bullet of Known alloy and my fresh Alloy against each other both from the same mold, when they squashed flat they were the same. NOT SO. The Alloy would on occasion throw a flier that I called good. Finally the Black Powder and Antimony struck a Bell. Sold off all my made up Alloy and went to Pure Lead, Pure Tin and the Fliers LESSEND, my score went up. Now wrote the occasional fliers off to ME! My son is a Material Science Professor at UVA in
Virginia. We have had this conversations more than a few times and he has made me aware of some of the flaw's available with mixing Alloy's with more than two materials. Once you start that you lose all real control of what you produce. He gave me some advise on the Benefits ? or Flaws of dropping bullets into a Bucket of Water. Will elaborate on that if it would be of interest.
But this conversation started as a Hardness figure. So we can talk about the water quench at another time. FITZ. OLD TUCK