Page Index Toggle Pages: 1 [2]  Send TopicPrint
Hot Topic (More than 10 Replies) .25-20's, more or less (Read 16237 times)
PETE
Ex Member


Re: .25-20's, more or less
Reply #15 - Jul 10th, 2004 at 10:27pm
Print Post  
2520,
  Well, was just curious if you'd used BP in your WCF. We got to talking about that cal. at the match today, The consensus seemed to be that it should be a decent cartridge if chambered in something other than a lever action.

  It'll be awfully tempting to to barrel the Low Wall action I'm getting from Ken in it. As I mentioned I could put on my current barrel in .25SS, which has a 1-10" twist, and I found out today that I could get a barrel with the original 1-14" twist.

  Appreciate you letting us know what loads seem to work the best in your 44. Will be good starting points if I decide to go that way.

  Those 44's aren't very strong are they!? I've lost count of how many links and pins I've made for them, but never had a quarrel with how they shot.

PETE
  
Back to top
 
IP Logged
 
granute
Ex Member


Re: .25-20's, more or less
Reply #16 - Jun 16th, 2005 at 12:20am
Print Post  
FWIW - I've been using the Bertram 25/20SS brass in my M44
Stevens  with zero splits. I anneal newly purchased cases
by the old 'stand them in a baking pan with cold water that
covers the bottom half of the case - and heat the brass to
a dull red- to include the full neck' then knock it over in the
water and go to the next one method......
So far, I've done 250 cases and fired them with 7.5 gr #4227
with a commercial 85 gr bullet at .259 dia.  I wish they'd use
a softer lube instead of the blue crap, but thats how it goes
when you buy rather than cast your own....
  
Back to top
 
IP Logged
 
JDSteele
Ex Member


Re: .25-20's, more or less
Reply #17 - Jun 16th, 2005 at 11:25pm
Print Post  
FWIW......
I've used the Green Mountain light octagon contour barrels in 25 cal to rebarrel a low wall and a small Martini. These little octagon barrels are the same contour/taper as the Winchester lever action rifles, and were intended for the Cowboy Action crowd for the most part. They are 1:14 twist and have proven to be accurate in my so far limited testing.

These barrels as they come from GM have a small tulip or flare at the breech, left over from the machining process. I found that this tulip really went well with the appearance of the low wall rifle, and so I left it. It turned out to be very reminiscent of some of Steven Dodd Hughes' single shots, although not quite as pronounced. The octagon taper was very slightly smaller than the original Winchester #1 size and the original forearm fit like a glove after I inletted slightly for the tulip. I also turned the bbl to a half-round contour with a wedding-band transition, for a somewhat different look.

Unfortunately the little Martini's narrow frame didn't look right with the tulip, so it ended up being straight octagon all the way.

The low wall rifle had originally been chambered in 25-20 SS and then later reamed to 25-20 WCF, without being set back. Needless to say, the fired cases presented a VERY unusual appearance! I chambered the new GM bbl in 25-20 WCF and had John King mark the barrel with the Winchester logo and caliber designation. It shot into 1.25 MOA with jacketed bullets in very limited testing before I returned it to my friend the owner.

The Martini became a 256 Win Mag, and it also shot into 1.25 MOA in limited testing with jacketed bullets. I personally believe both barrels will do better, with better bullets and a better shooter.

I've been told that 25 SS cases can be swaged from 222 Rem brass, after a relief groove has been cut just ahead of the rim recess. The resulting rim would be a little thin but this method would certainly work.

My experience with Bertram brass in 50-70 and 50-110 was that not all cases would fit into the shell holders and also a number of cases had obvious folds in the walls, places where the swaging or drawing process had actually created an inclusion in the brass instead of smoothly reforming it. Kinda dangerous, to say the least.
Good luck, Joe
  
Back to top
 
IP Logged
 
PETE
Ex Member


Re: .25-20's, more or less
Reply #18 - Jun 19th, 2005 at 11:28am
Print Post  
Joe,

  You're right about .25/20SS brass being able to be made from .222/223 brass. I made 300 that way for myself and a friend has made several hundred for the local shooters. Your comment on the SS rim thickness being made from .22 brass being a little thin would depend on how your rifle was chambered and in, I suppose, what time frame. Seems some were chambered for a thicker rim, and when ordering them many years ago from GainTwist they asked which I had.

  Your experiences with Bertram brass mirrors mine. Even after annealing them twice I got a 20% reject rate after five firings. At $1.50 apiece this is what caused us to look into making our own. All experienced splits on the side of the case below the "neck". I never checked for the problem you mention but would suspect it was for the same reason. I've fired 100 of my own cases over ten times now, and only had three failures.... which were due to expanded primer pockets when pushing load development to far.

  When annealing the Bertram cases they didn't seem to react the same way as other cases made of cartridge brass did so took them into work and subjected them to an NDE nuclear bombardment test which did show they were made of cartridge brass. So at this point in time I'm not sure what Bertram is/was doing to cause this problem.

PETE
  
Back to top
 
IP Logged
 
waterman
Frequent Elocutionist
*****
Offline



Posts: 2889
Location: Behind the Redwood Curtain
Joined: Jun 9th, 2004
Re: .25-20's, more or less
Reply #19 - Jun 19th, 2005 at 5:30pm
Print Post  
I think all of us experiencing longitudinal splits are looking at an artifact of the brass extrusion process.  I do not know anything about the process except that drawing and extrusion are said to be different processes.

We have noticed how our old (1935 era?) .25-20 SS and .28-30 Stevens (much older) cartridge cases seem to last and last, at least as long as we stick to mild loads.  Those old cases were drawn, which as I understand it is a different process.  What I have read about extrusion indicates that it was not used on a production basis until the 1940s.  Can anyone add anything about the extrusion process?

Does anyone use larger cartridges from Bell or Bertram?  Any problems there?   

I have not experienced any longitudinal splits in my new .25-20 Repeater cases with R-P headstamps or with any of my .32-20 brass.  I assume those are drawn cases, simply because the big companies acquired their machinery for making such cases a very long time ago.

I have not yet purchased any RMC brass.  Comments here by other say it is turned from rod stock by CNC machines.  Does this brass have thin walls like a basic brass that we later form with our dies?  Or is there just a cylindrical hole bored into the center of the rod stock and the outside of the rid turned to the OD specs for the cartridge case?

  
Back to top
 
IP Logged
 
PETE
Ex Member


Re: .25-20's, more or less
Reply #20 - Jun 19th, 2005 at 11:41pm
Print Post  
Waterman,

  Can't help you much on the extrusion process other than what you probably know already.

  I am using .50/90 BELL brass and have found nothing wrong with it. Good stuff as far as I'm concerned!

  I don't think you'll have much trouble with the "Name" brand brass other than they'll wear out over time and develop neck splits. Other than a piece or two wearing out prematurely they seem to last for as long as you'd expect.

  As to RMC brass I have a 100 cases in .28/30 and with several firings thru them I haven't had a reject yet. Yes... They are machined from bar stock. I can't comment on what type brass they use but there predecessor used Naval Brass. If you'll go upstream on this thread you'll see where I've posted the PMI test for GainTwists brass, which I will assume RMC is also using.

  RMC brass.... without dissecting a case...... appears to be machined the same internal dim.'s as drawn brass. That is the case walls will get thicker as you go down into the case. The wall thickness at the mouth runs about the same thickness as drawn brass. The necks show they have been annealed after machining. And it is turned out on CNC machines. The nice thing about turning cases is you can specify any primer pocket you'd like and also have them make you Everlasting cases if you'd like.

PETE
  
Back to top
 
IP Logged
 
Page Index Toggle Pages: 1 [2] 
Send TopicPrint