Green_Frog wrote on Feb 21
st, 2025 at 10:16pm:
I’m surprised no one has mentioned this. I am a strong devotee of Winter ‘wall, bath high and low, but if I were serious about rimfire BPCS and choosing between the two rifles you mention, the Stevens copy would win hands down. (Don’t hurt yourself laughing ledball!)
The Winchester has one major design flaw, found only in the 22 rf, that abominable extractor! Ballard is better, Stevens is better, basically everybody had a better design than one that had the firing pin strike the rim that was on a moving surface. If I had a custom built rifle and knew what I know now, it wouldn’t have that extractor.
This is my opinion based on experience with my own custom barreled (Shilen) low wall Winder Musket, YMMV.
Froggie
DZ makes an 1885 extractor located at 9:00 o'clock and has an ejector. I had DZ barrel a low-wall for my young son. It is a good choice.
I used to shoot a Cody Ballard, Baldwin iron sights with a 30 inch barrel and it was 100% capable of hitting everything. The whole setup was just a little small for me.
Mostly now, I shoot the CPA scoped with the old MVA 28" and Schuetzen scope mount. It has a Douglass 16 twist and
delivers for me. It has a very heavy 26 inch round barrel. I can't shoot light rifles offhand for squat. Short light barrels don't hold for me.
Texas Mac - I have never shortened a barrel, so I have no experience. Just a comment on velocity.... we have been chronographing our 22rf match ammo (again) since the Garman chrono units came on the scene. To my surprise, the Eley I shoot has "Eley's" tested lot velocity on the box. each lot is labeled with its own tested velocity, and I buy it based on their stated velocity. As an example, mine and other rifleman find their ammo runs 40fps +/- over the Eley lot/FPS number - well over 1100 FPS So my question -What would the velocity be if I shot a 16 inch barrel, almost 1200FPS? and how is Eley getting such slow speeds (1065FPS) and what barrel length are they using to test velocity? Super-duper long???
The suggestion of going to a faster than 16 twist is also interesting. I have no direct experience - two low-walls, a Ballard and a CPA. All 16 twist. GT has been telling me of his testing with fast and really fast twist 22rf's. I am not sure I could tell!!! It would take setting up two rifles with ammo it likes and a lot of shooting. Sure sounds like fun!!!
-Michael Rix