Firstly, for those of you who wish to nit-pick the important but frustrating topic of pre-WWI Stevens catalogs yet again, I encourage you to engage the Forum’s SEARCH option to find the related topic that Redsetter and I “chaired” (back about this time in 2018 as I remember). For now, I’m going to make only two comments: 1. Red, myself, and a substantial number of contributors to our survey eventually concluded that Cornell’s Stevens catalogs specifically cannot be trusted as to covers, date assignments, and sometimes even contents. Indeed, I’ll go even further out on my own limb and opine that Rob and Abby are in it far more for the money than any desire to preserve history or expand knowledge. 2. Too many Stevens catalogs are not actually dated and the best one can do is search them for clues (often minute and sometimes conjectural) that make a date assignment reasonable. For example, I don’t know of any Stevens catalog that’s “reliably dated” to either 1901 or 1902. However, according to my notes, Forum member BP reported that his No. 50 catalog contains the text "On January 1, 1902, we were the largest producers of firearms for sporting purposes in the world." Unfortunately, BP didn’t mention whether his catalog was an original or reprint or give its page count. (As posted earlier, there are at least two No. 50 catalogs, which can be most easily distinguished by their page counts.) In short, I can only hope that someday, someone who has amassed a definitive collection of original Stevens catalogs, hopefully with their postally-dated shipping envelopes, will be moved to create a monograph settling these questions. Bill Lawrence
|