The 10-shots-per-target would work fine if we were shooting short relays and only one target up at a time. But with longer relays and multiple targets in play few of us shoot ten consecutive shots at one target.
Frankly I'm just beginning to try offhand shooting, with the 22s, ANYTHING that would increase my score would help my ego, but the 50yd targets don't allow the "anything that hits the paper counts for something" rule.
I personally don't see as how it would really have much impact. I have a hard time imagining a situation where it would affect the top ten order in any given match. The top shooters won't be hurt by it and it would help encourage the "have-nots" to keep trying.
In my relatively short time in the ASSRA the single most common complaint is the lack of new shooters. It is discussed and cussed by almost e veryone and at every event. "how do we get more, new recruits to the game. Besides the obvious cost of the sport, the daunting gap between the scores of the good shooters and the rest of us is another factor.
I HAVE talked to a number of repeat non-shooting visitors to the EG matches. These are guys who have the guns and who shoot them elsewhere but won't compete because their scores wouldn't be worth it.
I posit that that allowing the any-hit-counts-for-something rule is to encourage the entry level shooters. As I recall from history thats why they allowed it in the Muzzleloading days and why it got carried over into the early ASSRA.
There are actually quite a few Offhand shooters at the EG matches. A lot more than are reflected in the published match results since a large majority of the targets fired are never turned in. There are a lot of offhand shooters who never turn one in so their name doesn't show up.
Its pretty easy for us to play the "old-time" card when we are riding out our pet peeves, whether its actions, calibres, powders, sights, or rules. I'm sure there are a lot of things that the "old-timers" would find perplexing about the way we play their game now. some they'd turn their nose up at, others they'd grab with both hands and run with. .
Just my extremely personal opinion
wayne